How Similar Are Grokipedia and Wikipedia? A Multi-Dimensional Textual and Structural Comparison
2510.26899v1
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.SI
2025-11-04
Авторы:
Taha Yasseri
Abstract
The launch of Grokipedia, an AI-generated encyclopedia developed by Elon
Musk's xAI, was presented as a response to perceived ideological and structural
biases in Wikipedia, aiming to produce "truthful" entries via the large
language model Grok. Yet whether an AI-driven alternative can escape the biases
and limitations of human-edited platforms remains unclear. This study
undertakes a large-scale computational comparison of 382 matched article pairs
between Grokipedia and Wikipedia. Using metrics across lexical richness,
readability, structural organization, reference density, and semantic
similarity, we assess how closely the two platforms align in form and
substance. The results show that while Grokipedia exhibits strong semantic and
stylistic alignment with Wikipedia, it typically produces longer but less
lexically diverse articles, with fewer references per word and more variable
structural depth. These findings suggest that AI-generated encyclopedic content
currently mirrors Wikipedia's informational scope but diverges in editorial
norms, favoring narrative expansion over citation-based verification. The
implications highlight new tensions around transparency, provenance, and the
governance of knowledge in an era of automated text generation.
Ссылки и действия
Дополнительные ресурсы: